E.I. Technology Unlimited Company v Hispec Electrical Products Limited [2026] EWHC 2953 (IPEC)
The Claimant, “EIT”, brought a claim for infringement of its European Patent (UK) No. 1 906 371 B1 (the “Patent”) in relation to an interconnected alarm system sold by the Defendant (“HiSpec”). HiSpec counterclaimed for invalidity of the Patent on the basis the Patent lacked novelty and inventive step. By trial, only validity was in issue.
The Patent related to interconnected smoke, heat or carbon-monoxide alarms using a single interconnect wire both to make all alarms sound and to carry voltage-based signals from a remote control unit for the test, hush and locate functions.
Two pieces of prior art were relied on by HiSpec – EIT’s earlier Ei 159 System, which used an interconnect wire and remote locator switch, and a patent application known as “Kaiser”.
HHJ Hacon held that claim 1 of the Patent lacked novelty in light of the Ei 159 System and both claims 5 and 13 lacked an independent inventive step.
As to Kaiser, EIT had stated in [0004] of the Patent that Kaiser discloses an alarm system according to the preamble of claim 1. EIT approved that statement during prosecution before the Examining Division and subsequently obtained grant of the Patent. In the litigation, EIT adopted an inconsistent position and argued that specific integers in the preamble of claim 1 were not disclosed by Kaiser. HHJ Hacon held that this was conduct not in the public interest and amounted to an abuse of process. He barred EIT from advancing a case inconsistent with [0004] of the Patent. He nevertheless went on to consider inventive step in relation to claim 1 as a whole and held that claim 1 lacked inventive step over Kaiser.
Hugo Cuddigan KC and Mitchell Beebe appeared for the Defendant, instructed by Gowling WLG