Fibrogen v Akebia & Astellas v Akebia [2021] EWCA Civ 1279

Patent validity, insufficiency

This was an appeal of the findings of insufficiency and the obviousness of the Family B patents in the judgment of Arnold LJ ([2020] EWHC 866 (Pat)).

Birss LJ Arnold LJ had construed the claims incorrectly and applied the wrong test. Birss LJ held that the correct approach is to ask whether it is possible to make a reasonable prediction that the invention will work with substantially everything falling within the scope of the claim. In determining the scope of the claim compounds Birss LJ distinguished between two types of functional limitations: those that determine the scope of the claimed class and those that describe the technical effect to be achieved by the claimed compounds. He set out the following three-step approach:
(1) Identify what it is which falls within the scope of the claimed class;
(2) Determine what it means to say that the invention works (i.e. what is it for?);
(3) Answer the question whether it is possible to make a reasonable prediction the invention will work with substantially everything falling within the scope of the claim.

By this approach so-called step 1 functional features define the scope of the claimed compounds which are then assessed for plausibility rather than asking whether all compounds with the claimed structural features will have the claimed functional features. Accordingly Birss LJ found that the claims were not insufficient.

The appeal in respect of the finding that the Family B Patents were obvious was dismissed.

The Supreme Court have granted Akebia permission to appeal. The appeal will be heard in 2024.

[2021] EWCA Civ 1279

Latest News

Anna Edwards-Stuart appointed King’s Counsel

Chambers is delighted to announce that Anna Edwards-Stuart has been appointed King’s Counsel in the 2023 competition, announced on 19th January 2024.

Miruna Bercariu joins 11 South Square

Chambers is delighted to announce Miruna Bercariu has accepted an offer of tenancy after a successful pupillage and will commence practice immediately....

Chambers UK Bar Awards 2023

Chambers is thrilled to announce we have won all three of the awards we were nominated for at the Chambers UK Bar Awards 2023. 11 South Square, IT/IP Set of the Year Brian Nicholson KC, IT/IP Silk of the Year Ka...

Edward Cronan joins 11 South Square

We are pleased to announce the arrival of a new member of chambers, Edward Cronan. Edward first came on to our radar at 11 South Square when he was a solicitor, and we watched his move to the bar in 2018 with interest. S...

Bio-science Law Review – University Inventions: When is a student a consumer?

University Inventions: When is a student a consumer? Oxford University Innovation Limited v Oxford Nanoimaging Limited [2022] EWHC 3200 (Pat) This article provides a case comment on the Judgment of Daniel Alexander KC...

Michael Silverleaf called to the Irish Bar

Chambers is pleased to announce that Michael Silverleaf has been called to the Irish Bar and has appeared in that role as part of a team representing Bristol-Myers Squibb in the Irish High Court before Barrett J. The tri...

Lionel Bently made Honorary King’s Counsel

Chambers is delighted to announce that Lionel Bently has been made an Honorary King's Counsel. Honorary KCs are awarded to those who have made a major contribution to the law of England and Wales, outside practice in...