Thomas Pink Shirtmaker LLC v Victorias Secret Stores Brand Management LLC [2026] EWHC 2817 (BP)
This case concerns the construction of a clause restricting the assertion of trade mark rights within a worldwide Settlement and Co-Existence Agreement (“SA”), concluded in 2015 following the judgment of Birss J (as he was then) in Thomas Pink Ltd v Victoria’s Secret UK Ltd [2014] EWHC 2631 (Ch).
In September 2026, Victoria’s Secret brought a claim for trade mark infringement in the Southern District of Ohio (“the Ohio Proceedings”), complaining of the sale of a range of athleisure womenswear prominently branded with the word PINK. Thomas Pink asserted that Victoria’s Secret was barred from bringing their claim by Clause 5.5 of the SA. Victoria’s Secret responded by arguing that the Ohio Proceedings fell within an exception to Clause 5.5 contained in Clause 5.5.2.
The SA included an exclusive jurisdiction clause in favour of the English Courts in relation to any disputes “arising out of or in connection with” it. Both sides had issued Part 8 claims seeking determination of the scope of Clause 5.5 / 5.5.2. Thomas Pink also sought an anti-suit injunction and damages for breach of contract. The trial of both claims was expedited and heard by Mr Justin Turner KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, in October 2026.
The Court rejected Thomas Pink’s primary argument that the phrase “associated with a brand or business” within subclause 5.5.2 included commercial association (i.e. the existence of a licensor-licensee relationship) rather than being (as Victoria’s Secret had argued) limited to association in a trade mark sense. Thomas Pink’s secondary argument, that a reference on internal garment labels and/or swing tags to Thomas Pink as the licensor of the goods brought them outside the scope of Clause 5.5.2, was also rejected as requiring an interpretation of the SA that would be inconsistent with Birss J’s judgment.
Thomas Pink’s application for an anti-suit injunction was refused. Whether Thomas Pink’s products actually infringe Victoria’s Secret’s US trade marks remains a matter to be determined by the Ohio Court.
Anna Edwards-Stuart KC appeared for the Thomas Pink parties.
Michael Silverleaf KC and David Ivison appeared for the Victoria’s Secret parties.